New Zealand: court declares pay-equity law discriminatory
The High Court found the 2025 changes inconsistent with protection from sex discrimination. The law remains in force.

New Zealand’s High Court issued a declaration on 19 November that the Equal Pay Act, as amended in 2025, is inconsistent with the right to freedom from sex discrimination. The decision, [2026] NZHC 3597, concerns a challenge brought by trade unions against the Attorney-General.
The case concerns equal pay for work of equal value and addressing the undervaluation of female-dominated occupations. It goes beyond comparing male and female pay within a single employer.
According to the court’s complete official summary, the amendments ended existing claims and imposed stricter conditions for new ones, while also restricting comparisons between industries. The court found material disadvantage for women and held that the discrimination was not justified under the Bill of Rights Act.
A declaration of inconsistency does not invalidate the law, which remains in full force. It does not automatically restore previous claims or award pay rises.
The court rejected separate claims concerning natural justice and the right to bring civil proceedings, both in relation to urgent lawmaking without prior consultation and to the amendments’ content. The declaration concerns the prohibition of sex discrimination.
English translation of the Greek edition · Read in Greek